New Craft Supplies > Paper Crafts > Christmas: A Cherry On Top

New!

Gilded Garland Magical Shimmer Shaker 2.0 - Lindy's Gang

$5.50

New!

Snowberry Lane Elements Paper - Mintay Papers

$1.89

New!

Snowberry Lane 6x8 Add-On Paper Set - Mintay Papers

$7.09

New!

Build A Wreath Stamp Set With Framelits Dies By 49 and Market - Sizzix

$39.99

New!

Holiday Drop Stamp Set With Framelits Dies By 49 and Market - Sizzix

$24.99

New!

Holiday Tags Stamp Set With Framelits Dies By 49 and Market - Sizzix

$44.99

New!

Holiday Textures Stamp Set By 49 and Market - Sizzix

$39.99

New!

Tiny Gingerbread Man Dies - Trinity Stamps

$7.99

New!

Tiny Sheet Pan Dies - Trinity Stamps

$9.99

New!

Winter Stuffies Coordinating Dies - Trinity Stamps

$19.99

New!

Winter Stuffies Stamp Set - Trinity Stamps

$15.99

New!

Fa La La Coordinating Dies - Trinity Stamps

$18.99

New!

Fa La La Stamp Set - Trinity Stamps

$15.99

New!

Peppermint Swirl Stencil - Trinity Stamps

$7.99

New!

From Our Mouse To Yours Dies - Gina K Designs

$13.95

New!

Modern Holiday Greetings Dies - Gina K Designs

$13.95

New!

Snowy Silhouettes Dies - Gina K Designs

$25.95

New!

From Our Mouse To Yours Stamp Set - Gina K Designs

$10.95

New!

Modern Holiday Greetings Stamp Set - Gina K Designs

$10.95

New!

Snowy Silhouettes Stamp Set - Gina K Designs

$23.95

New!

A Christmas Story Mini Sticker Book Keychain - Pipsticks

$12.95

New!

Buddy The Elf Stickers - Pipsticks

$5.45

New!

Elf Junk Journal Sticker Book - Pipsticks

$21.95

New!

Elf Mini Sticker Book Keychain - Pipsticks

$12.95

New!

Elf Washi Tape - Pipsticks

$12.95

New!

Snowberry Lane Flora Paper - Mintay Papers

$1.89

New!

Snowberry Lane 12x12 Paper Set - Mintay Papers

$17.89

New!

Snowberry Lane 8x8 Paper Set - Mintay Papers

$9.99

New!

Snowberry Lane Elements Paper Stickers - Mintay Papers

$5.49

New!

Snowberry Lane Words Paper Stickers - Mintay Papers

$5.49

New!

Snowberry Lane Chipboard Ephemera Sheet - Mintay Papers

$5.99

New!

Snowberry Lane Paper Ephemera - Mintay Papers

$10.89

New!

Snowberry Lane Paper Die-Cuts - Mintay Papers

$10.89

New!

Christmas Krinkle Confetti - Trinity Stamps

$5.49

New!

Holographic Holiday Confetti - Trinity Stamps

$5.49

New!

Snow People Stamp Set - Beyond Stamping

$24.99

New!

Christmas Market Stamp Set - Beyond Stamping

$24.99

New!

Santa's Winter Village - All-In-One Kit - 49 and Market

$34.99

New!

Santa's Winter Village Card Kit - 49 and Market

$21.99

New!

Jolly Jingles Bundle Collection Pack With Patch - 49 and Market

$39.99

New!

Jolly Jingles 12x12 Collection Pack - 49 and Market

$12.99

New!

Jolly Jingles 12x12 Solids Collection Pack - 49 and Market

$12.99

New!

Jolly Jingles 6x8 Collection Pack - 49 and Market

$12.99

New!

Santa Paper - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Festive Paper - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Holidays Paper - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Christmas Paper - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Jingle Bells Paper - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Merry Paper - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Joy Paper - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Advent Paper - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Solids Paper 1 - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Solids Paper 2 - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Solids Paper 3 - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Solids Paper 4 - Jolly Jingles - 49 and Market

$1.50

New!

Jolly Jingles Blendable Rub-On Transfer Set - 49 and Market

$8.99

New!

Jolly Jingles Laser Cut Elements - 49 and Market

$8.99

New!

Jolly Jingles Ephemera Set - 49 and Market

$8.99

New!

Jolly Jingles Washi Sticker Set - 49 and Market

$5.99

New!

Jolly Jingles Chipboard Set - 49 and Market

$7.99

New!

Christmas Spirit Stamp Set - Tim Holtz - Stampers Anonymous

$29.95

New!

Mini Stencil Set #63 - Tim Holtz - Stampers Anonymous

$12.99

New!

Retro Diamond Layering Stencil - Tim Holtz - Stampers Anonymous

$6.99

New!

Retro Snowflake Layering Stencil - Tim Holtz - Stampers Anonymous

$6.99

New!

Retro Pinwheel Layering Stencil - Tim Holtz - Stampers Anonymous

$6.99

New!

Christmas Doodles Stamp Set - Tim Holtz - Stampers Anonymous

$29.95

New!

Wonderment Stamp Set - Tim Holtz - Stampers Anonymous

$29.95

New!

Holiday Botanical Stamp Set - Tim Holtz - Stampers Anonymous

$24.95

New!

Christmas Bells - Tim Holtz Idea-ology

$7.99

New!

Christmas Palette Collection 8x8 Paper Pad - Tim Holtz Idea-ology

$7.99

New!

Christmas 2026 Confections - Tim Holtz Idea-ology

$7.99

New!

Christmas Palette Collection 12x12 Paper Pad - Tim Holtz Idea-ology

$12.99

New!

Christmas Metallic Gold + Silver Kraft Stock - Tim Holtz Idea-ology

$11.99

New!

Christmas 2026 Baseboards + Transparencies - Tim Holtz Idea-ology

$10.99

New!

Winter Forest Backdrop: Landscape Lawn Cuts - Lawn Fawn

$28.00

New!

Winter Forest Backdrop: Portrait Lawn Cuts - Lawn Fawn

$28.00

New!

Winter Lights Stencil - Waffle Flower Crafts

$13.00

New!

Nutcracker Sentiments Stamp Set - Waffle Flower Crafts

$16.00

New!

Nutcracker Sentiments Matching Die - Waffle Flower Crafts

$22.00

New!

Nutcracker Die - Waffle Flower Crafts

$12.00

New!

Postage Collage Nutcracker Stencil - Waffle Flower Crafts

$25.00

New!

Postage Collage Christmas Icons Die - Waffle Flower Crafts

$16.00

New!

Square Postage Nutcracker Stencil - Waffle Flower Crafts

$7.00

New!

Happy Drum Die - Waffle Flower Crafts

$20.00

New!

Joy Sentiments Stamp Set - Waffle Flower Crafts

$16.00

New!

Joy Sentiments Matching Die - Waffle Flower Crafts

$12.00

New!

Simply Christmas Stamp Set - Waffle Flower Crafts

$16.00

New!

Simply Christmas Matching Die - Waffle Flower Crafts

$22.00

New!

Subsentiments Christmas Diecut - Waffle Flower Crafts

$2.00

New!

Christmas Keepsakes 12x12 Collection Pack - Uniquely Creative

$24.39

New!

Christmas Keepsakes 6x6 Collection Pack - Uniquely Creative

$12.89

New!

Christmas Keepsakes Creative Cuts - Uniquely Creative

$7.09

New!

Christmas Keepsakes Coordinating Cardstock Bundle - Uniquely Creative

$12.99

New!

Evergreen Lane Paper - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$1.89

New!

Merry Little Things Paper - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$1.89

New!

Letters To Santa Paper - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$1.89

New!

The Nutcracker Paper - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$1.89

New!

Treasured Trinkets Paper - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$1.89

New!

Home For The Holidays Paper - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$1.89

New!

Good Tidings Paper - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$1.89

New!

Christmas Keepsakes Cut-A-Part Sheet - Uniquely Creative

$1.59

New!

Christmas Keepsakes Cut-A-Part Sheet Mini - Uniquely Creative

$1.59

New!

Christmas Keepsakes Glitter Dimensional Stickers - Uniquely Creative

$7.09

New!

Christmas Keepsakes Foiled Decorative Base Layer - Uniquely Creative

$3.49

New!

Holly Overlay - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$2.59

New!

Christmas Floral Ephemera - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$5.69

New!

Candy Stripes Stencil - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$8.59

New!

Christmas Embossing Folder - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$7.79

New!

Layered Poinsettia Dies - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$15.19

New!

Merry Christmas Tree Dies - Christmas Keepsakes - Uniquely Creative

$15.19

New!

Christmas Keepsakes Creative Magazine - Uniquely Creative

$9.29

New!

Cozy Dogs Lawn Cuts - Lawn Fawn

$20.00

New!

Gingerbread House Stamp Set - Lawn Fawn

$16.00

New!

Gingerbread House Lawn Cuts - Lawn Fawn

$17.00

New!

Gingerbread House Add-On Stamp Set - Lawn Fawn

$4.00

New!

Gingerbread House Add-On Lawn Cuts - Lawn Fawn

$7.00

New!

Big Hugs Penguin Lawn Cuts - Lawn Fawn

$18.00

New!

Giant Season's Greetings Lawn Cuts - Lawn Fawn

$12.00

New!

Frosted Flurries Foil Paper - Lawn Fawn

$1.50

New!

Ginger Snap Foil Paper - Lawn Fawn

$1.50

New Craft Supplies/Paper Crafts/Christmas (180)